Skip to content
Nerdly
News · Movies

Clayface heads for a No.1 US opening as James Gunn hails its rare A- CinemaScore

DC Studios' $44 million body horror took $10.4 million on Friday and is tracking for around $24 million, while audiences gave it the same A- grade as Superman.

DC Studios’ body horror gamble is paying off with the people who matter most: the ones buying tickets. Clayface took $10.4 million in North America on Friday, a figure that includes Thursday night previews, and is on course to finish its first weekend at the top of the US chart. Audiences leaving the cinema also handed it an A- CinemaScore, and James Gunn was quick to point out how unusual that is for a horror film.

According to Deadline, the Warner Bros. release is now heading for somewhere between $24 million and $25 million across its three-day debut from 3,458 North American screens. The Hollywood Reporter puts it at roughly $24 million, a touch below the $25 million to $30 million the studio had originally pencilled in, with another $4.3 million coming from overseas on Friday alone.

A small budget and a big grade

Those numbers look a lot healthier once you factor in the price tag. Clayface reportedly cost $44 million to make, a fraction of the $170 million spent on Supergirl, which opened to $37.1 million over the summer. Directed by James Watkins, the R-rated film stars Tom Rhys Harries as Matt Hagen, a Hollywood actor whose face is ruined, and Naomi Ackie as the scientist he turns to for help.

The A- grade puts Clayface level with Gunn’s own Superman as the best-received film of the new DCU so far. Supergirl landed a B- and The Flash a B, while horror releases tend to sit somewhere in the B or C bracket. Writing on Threads, the DC Studios co-chief said: “Really proud of this. Sinners is the only horror movie to have EVER gotten an A Cinemascore,” before adding that only Obsession and Weapons had matched the A- in recent years. He signed off with: “As always, all praise goes to James, Mike, Hossein, Tom, Naomi and the whole gang.”

If you missed it at the time, our Sinners Blu-ray review explains why Ryan Coogler’s film is the benchmark Gunn is measuring against.

Young crowds and premium screens

Deadline’s breakdown shows 73% of the opening audience was aged 18 to 34, and premium large format screens are bringing in close to half of the weekend takings even without IMAX, which is still tied up with Street Fighter. Critics have been warmer than they were to Supergirl too, with Clayface holding 76% on Rotten Tomatoes from reviewers and 94% from audiences.

The competition is far from toothless. A24’s Elizabeth Holmes documentary You Can See Everything made $6.1 million on its second Friday and could reach $20 million for the weekend, while Laika’s stop-motion Wildwood picked up $4.2 million on Friday along with an A CinemaScore of its own.

In UK cinemas now

British fans did not have to wait. Clayface arrived in UK cinemas on 23 October, the same day as its American release, with an 18 certificate, and Warner Bros. UK marked the occasion in suitably gooey fashion.

Studio estimates for the full weekend are expected later today, with final figures following on Monday, and the second weekend will run straight into Halloween. For more on where DC goes next, revisit our look at the first Supergirl trailer and keep an eye on our news section.