Nerdly Presents: Should You Grade It – Episode 1: Pokemon, Godzilla & More!
Welcome to Should You Grade It?, the show where I take comics and trading cards from my collection and decide – usually on gut instinct, misplaced optimism, or sheer chaos – whether they deserve to be sent off for grading.

This isn’t a hyper-technical breakdown of every microscopic flaw. It’s about the fun of the hobby: the thrill of slabbing something you love, the gamble of chasing a higher grade, the hope that this time maybe the graders won’t break my heart, and the excitement of seeing a favourite comic or card immortalised in plastic.
If you enjoy watching collectors talk themselves into (or out of) sending stuff to be graded, you’re in the right place.
- Subscribe for more grading adventures
- Tell me if you would grade it or leave it raw!




































